March 22, 2004

Apache projects to remove author tags

Cocoon

I've recently found that the Apache Cocoon project, and perhaps other projects too, are going to remove @author tags from the source code. There seem to be few reasons for such a move:

  • the @author tag tells who wrote the skeleton of the code first, and not who contributed further to it, documented it etc.
  • the "selling" of ASF-branded code is impeded by @author tags present in the code. They do not emphasize the quality control of the community behind that code.
  • the apparent lack of legal protection if your name appears as author in the source code.

I strongly believe none of these reasons are valid, and I would be very dissappointed to see such a move happen.

I've contributed a fair amount of code to Free Software Foundation and Apache Foundation, among other free software/open source projects. And it is the first time I hear claims such as those mentioned above.

Over the years, FSF has done a very good job of protecting the software donated to it. FSF, just like Apache, requires contributors to assign the copyright to their work to the Foundation. From that moment all the legal claims are handled by FSF automatically, and the author is fully protected from whatever legal threats. The third argument above makes no sense to me. I don't see how removing the @author tags will prevent this from happening. It's not like the software appeared in CVS by magic: some person committed it, whether the @author tag documents it or not.

The history of modifications in a file provides 1) due credit to people writing the code and 2) useful hints on the evolution of a particular piece of code. Take this file as an example. You can see a rough history of an apparently simple, yet very important piece of the GNU Objective-C runtime.

Contrary to the liberal view that community writes the software, I don't think this is the case, at least not initially. Writing software is something very personal which requires not only craft, but also inspiration; it takes time and energy for something to materialize. The process is obviously influenced by a lot of feedback, but in the end is that one individual that writes the initial code. Further improvements of the code also require an understanding of the original ideas, and dedication to improve them. The process is driven by peer recognition and respect; the @author comments document that creation process. Removing them anihilates that recognition.

[Some years ago I was working on implementing a new feature in the GCC Objective-C frontend and runtime library. The initial solution I had in mind needed support of the linker on all the GCC supported platforms and support in libgcc.a, a runtime library distributed by GCC on every platform. I was not sure that was the right thing to do, so I asked on the dev mailing list people's opinion. Nobody was clueful enough to give an authoritative answer, and the original contributors to the code were no longer involved with the code. As a last resort, I asked the original author in a private email his opinion. Sure enough, he replied the next day with his thoughts. After a few other email exchanges, it became clear I needed to think of a different solution. The solution I came up with in the end is machine independent and doesn't require any linker support. Without knowledge of the author and contact information, that would have been a lot more difficult.]

Not having @author tags within comments reminds me of the days working for a large company. You would look at the code alone, with no metadata associated whatsoever, like author tags. If you found a problem or wanted to improved the code, the only way for you to act was to notify the corporation: your manager, some other manager etc., but not the developer himself/herself. People other than developers were in charge and deciding what to do with the code you or your colleague wrote. This ends up promoting an atmosphere were peer recognition is no longer important, and were writing code is no longer the primary focus of a community. For open source software development this would be extremely bad. Open-source software is, above all, about software.

I hope ASF people will seriously reconsider the idea of removing the @author tags.

Posted by ovidiu at March 22, 2004 10:26 PM |
 
Copyright © 2002-2016 Ovidiu Predescu.